Skip to main content
EnviTrail

News

Carbon footprint 3 – the Scope 3 bogeyman

Companies often already know how to measure direct emissions and where to find information on emissions from electricity generation. But how do you measure emissions that a company has no direct control over? In the third part of our CO2 footprint series, we explain which emissions are counted under Scope 3. You will learn how to start measuring indirect emissions, and we add a few tips on reducing Scope 3 emissions effectively.

When calculating a carbon footprint under the GHG Protocol, we talk about scopes. Scope 1 covers direct emissions, i.e. emissions the company influences directly through its activities – mainly emissions from stationary and mobile fuel combustion and from industrial processes. An important category of direct greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions is fugitive emissions, which arise from the direct release of greenhouse gases into the atmosphere from various types of equipment and processes. Common sources of fugitive emissions include refrigeration and air-conditioning systems (specifically leaked refrigerants), fire-suppression systems (leaked extinguishing agents) and the purchase and release of technical gases.

Scope 2 covers indirect but easily identifiable emissions from purchased electricity, heat, steam or cooling, i.e. emissions that are linked to the company’s activities but do not arise within the company itself.

Scope 3 consists of so-called indirect emissions. These mainly include emissions from the production of the materials used (for example electronics and office supplies), services (for example translation services and external accounting) and capital goods, as well as emissions from the disposal and treatment of waste generated by the company. Scope 3 also covers emissions from employee business travel and commuting and emissions from transport and distribution provided by the company and its suppliers.

Direct emissions are easy to calculate; indirect ones are the problem

In practice, we find that companies calculate their direct emissions and emissions from purchased energy fairly easily. But when it comes to the data needed to calculate Scope 3 emissions, they hit a wall.

The data needed to calculate indirect emissions, such as data on purchased materials (their weight), transport and distribution, business travel, employee commuting or leasing (where the company leases assets or leases them out to other companies), is not easy to report. It is common for an accountant or another employee to spend a long time tracking this data down, or for it to be collected from employees through a survey.

Some of the data for the Scope 3 calculation also has to be obtained from suppliers. That is often practically impossible, especially with smaller companies or sole traders, unless the supplier already measures its own carbon footprint.

It pays to set up data collection in good time

At EnviTrail, we recommend the following approach, for which there is still time ahead of the upcoming CSRD implementation.

  • The company calculates at least Scope 1 and 2, i.e. the emissions it produces directly and its energy-related emissions.
  • During this exercise, which gives a clearer picture of how the company operates and how it manufactures products or delivers services, it determines what data to collect to calculate indirect emissions for the following year.
  • Collection of this data is set up so that the Scope 3 calculation can later be refined further without much administrative burden and with sufficient time in hand.

“As part of its preparation for Scope 3 reporting, ČSOB approached its most significant suppliers by financial volume of supplies (around 170 entities). One aim of the survey was to map the state of their CO2 footprint reporting and their readiness to provide this data. The responses showed that carbon footprint reporting is already under way mainly at large multinationals, particularly in ICT, but selected manufacturers, facility management providers and law and consultancy firms also responded positively. However, of the responses received, only around 25% came from companies that are able or willing to provide the data,” says Stanislava Slavíková Bízová, Purchasing and Services Manager at ČSOB.

Companies often have data on purchased materials only in monetary terms. The GHG Protocol does allow this category to be calculated on a spend basis, but because this data (including the emission factors) is of lower quality than when purchases are recorded by weight, the resulting emissions figure tends to be significantly distorted.

“Given the total number of suppliers in the ČSOB group (around 4,500 entities), it is unrealistic to obtain data directly from all of them, so we are considering the most suitable methods for calculating Scope 3 emissions under the GHG Protocol, i.e. spend-based, industry averages or a hybrid method,” adds Slavíková Bízová.

How to reduce Scope 3 emissions

Once a company has also calculated its indirect emissions, the next step is a decarbonisation strategy, which needs careful thought so that it achieves maximum impact and a good return even with minimal investment. It is best to start with the “low-hanging fruit”, i.e. easily achievable goals, and then move on to any larger investments.

Scope 3 can be influenced in practice, for example by carefully selecting suppliers of materials, carriers or distributors, or by encouraging employees to commute by public transport, car-sharing or bike.

In non-manufacturing companies, it is not unusual for employee commuting to account for more than 15% of the company’s carbon footprint. A large share of these emissions comes from people driving to work in their own cars. For example, we can offer employees an annual public transport pass as a benefit; this relatively cheap measure not only eases traffic in cities but, of course, also reduces the company’s carbon footprint.

Another tip for reducing your carbon footprint is to replace business trips with online meetings. An online meeting is always cheaper, takes less time and is often just as effective.

EnviTrail carbon footprint series

  1. Don’t be afraid to communicate your results transparently
  2. The carbon footprint in the context of ESG
  3. The Scope 3 bogeyman