Skip to main content
EnviTrail

News

Carbon footprint series 1 – don’t be afraid to communicate your results transparently

In this new series, we take a practical look at some, perhaps slightly controversial, topics related to the carbon footprint, one piece of the ESG methodology puzzle. The first instalment looks at the very first step that comes before carbon footprint reporting. We explain why companies should not be afraid to communicate the results of their carbon footprint audit transparently. Companies often showcase some of their activities to reduce their carbon footprint, but are reluctant to publish exact figures. They fear comparison with competitors, even though they are often comparing ‘apples with oranges’.

Benchmarking and the carbon footprint

In the context of the carbon footprint, benchmarking is the process of comparing greenhouse gas emission results between different companies in the same sector. The aim of benchmarking is to get an accurate picture of how companies in a given sector are performing on emissions. At a higher level, companies can compare their emissions with those of other companies in the same region or country. This lets them understand how their emissions compare with the regional or national average.

  • No carbon footprint figure is wrong; the aim is to understand the current situation and be able to compare results.
  • Calculation methods and data quality often differ. Because the data is inconsistent, today’s benchmarks are often hard to read and rankings can therefore be misleading.
  • For a comparison to make sense, the scope and quality of the input data must be the same. Harmonised reporting standards will help with this in future.
  • By publishing the results of their carbon footprint audit, companies can compare the scope of their calculations and clarify where they can extend the calculation and better implement carbon reduction strategies.
  • By publishing the results of their carbon footprint audit, companies contribute to greater transparency across the whole sector and set an example for others.

The emissions calculation methodology may differ between the companies being compared

The GHG Protocol requires a ‘best effort’ when collecting data for the calculation. If a company cannot obtain the highest-quality data (for fuel-based methods, which calculate the carbon footprint from the amount of fossil fuel consumed), a secondary calculation method can be used (distance-based, where the calculation is based on the distance travelled and the factor for the mode of transport), or even a tertiary one (spend-based, where the carbon footprint is calculated from spending on the product, service or fuel and the corresponding emission factor), which is based on the costs of the fuel, product or service. The point of this flexibility in the data collection methodology is to enable every company to obtain complete data for the calculation. The more effort a company puts into data collection, the better the calculation, and the more meaningful the results are for its subsequent decarbonisation strategy and process changes within the company. However, by no means all companies use data of the same quality for their calculations, so comparing yourself with competitors loses its meaning. Many companies are therefore afraid to share their results with others. Comparison will hopefully become easier in future thanks to common standards being developed at EU and international level, but for now the situation remains more complicated.

There is no such thing as a bad carbon footprint figure

Companies fear that their results will be seen as inadequate, which could lead to a loss of customers, business partners or credibility. It is important to realise that there is no bad number. Once you know where you stand on emissions, you can follow up with a decarbonisation strategy and, with an audit-based approach, you can also compare annual results, which is the basis for improvement. In addition to the result, you also need to know the scope of the calculation and keep expanding it, whether by collecting data in greater depth or by adding relevant categories to track. It is also important to see benchmarking not only as an evaluation tool but also as an information tool that helps you find room for improvement.

So why share your results?

By sharing their measurement results, companies can compare the scope of the calculation within their line of business. They find out whether a given measure only scratches the surface or goes deeper, and can then take steps towards more relevant results and therefore more effective measures. It is also important to share examples of good practice across sectors. When it comes to protecting nature and reducing emissions, we are ultimately all in the same boat, and practically at the very beginning.

This article was first published on our partner portal CSRD.cz

EnviTrail carbon footprint series

  1. Don’t be afraid to communicate your results transparently
  2. The carbon footprint in the context of ESG
  3. The Scope 3 bogeyman