Skip to main content
EnviTrail

News

Everything you need to know about ESG in ten minutes

There has been a flood of presentations on ESG, so if you want to stay up to date, we have put together a quick summary of the most important points about ESG.

What is ESG? How difficult is it to prepare an ESG report for a medium-sized or small company, and how much does it cost?

What ESG means

ESG stands for Environmental, Social and Governance (the way a company is run). You may know the older abbreviation CSR, Corporate Social Responsibility – ESG is, in a way, its successor.

The abbreviation ESG first appeared in 2005. The three pillars of ESG were not chosen at random: they correspond to the three pillars of sustainable development as promoted, for example, by the United Nations.

Sustainable development likewise rests on the environment, society and the economy, and some authors add a fourth pillar, culture. In essence, ESG is a tool for identifying non-financial risks and opportunities; it should give a company a basis for long-term decisions, but also, for example, input for marketing.

Although it is a non-financial reporting tool, ESG only makes sense if it is closely linked to the company's economic indicators. It is not reporting for reporting's sake; it is a very effective management tool. At EnviTrail we have found that many companies prepare an ESG report voluntarily and genuinely see it as a major market opportunity.

ESG and supply chains

In the Czech Republic ESG is not yet very common, but elsewhere in the world it is. In the UK, for example, a regulation has been in force since September 2021 that requires companies bidding for certain public contracts to produce non-financial reports. Germany has a similar law with universal application, not limited to public contracts. But make no mistake: ESG does not only concern large companies – through supply chains, and above all through banks, ESG will affect the vast majority of companies.

Construction is a good example. For decades, the construction industry has used various standards, such as the American LEED or the British BREEAM, which assess a building in terms of its environmental impact, occupant comfort and so on.

LEED, BREEAM and, more recently, WELL are now practically standard for every construction project. If you are a construction company, however small, and want to supply such a project, you have to report a whole range of indicators – in effect, you are producing an ESG report. And it makes no difference whether you are a multinational cement supplier or a small maker of designer light fittings. Everyone in the supply chain has to report.

Comparability of reports and standards

For ESG reporting to be of any use to a company, we need to be able to compare the ESG reports of different companies with each other. That is what standardisation is for, and so far there is little of it.

ESG is relatively new, so its form is not yet settled. The consultancy Ernst and Young calculated that in 2020 there were more than 600 different reporting methodologies worldwide. Some of them are fairly well established – construction, for example, uses the GRESB methodology, and European banks rely on the PCAF methodology.

The situation is clearer in carbon footprint reporting, where there are now practically only two very similar standards – the GHG Protocol and the ISO 14000 series. But even in ESG more generally, the range of methodologies in use is starting to narrow, with a preference for approaches that naturally link non-financial indicators to financial reports.

They are based mainly on the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS), which define, for example, the rules for audits. The TCFD methodology, developed by a team led by Michael Bloomberg and focused mainly on assessing risks and opportunities, also builds on them. The GRI methodology, by contrast, is typically accounting-based, to the point of having prescribed code lists, just like a chart of accounts.

These three methodologies – accounting-based IFRS, analytical TCFD and structured GRI – can be used together. It is a very comprehensive approach, used mainly by multinational corporations. For the carbon footprint, too, the approaches gaining ground are close to accounting and are, in effect, audits. This has two main advantages.

First, companies are not doing something entirely new but can draw on their experience and procedures from financial management.

Second, the result can be reviewed, sometimes even certified, so you avoid greenwashing. Calculating your carbon footprint with an online calculator is a good way to try it out, but for serious decisions you really need an audit.

The legislative context at the time

Faced with the challenge of unifying ESG reporting methodologies, the European Union has gone its own way, and for roughly the last ten years Europe has also been working towards a legislative framework for ESG. The aim is to assess environmental impact in particular with a tool called the EU Taxonomy, while a directive known by the abbreviation CSRD is being drawn up for ESG reporting. It will apply to all large companies active in the European Union.

The CSRD builds on established financial reporting standards and combines accounting-based IFRS, analytical TCFD and structured GRI, which we mentioned earlier.

For carbon footprint calculation, it allows for both the GHG Protocol and ISO standards. Admittedly, neither the EU Taxonomy nor the CSRD is at all popular among European companies. Their popularity is unfortunately not helped by the very complicated formal way in which they are described.

Which is rather a shame, because both the EU Taxonomy and the CSRD are built on very simple and intuitive principles. If we set aside the bureaucratic and legislative ballast, the EU Taxonomy and the CSRD are good tools for the strategic management of a company. And although the final wording of the CSRD is not yet known, its principles are already clear, which is why at EnviTrail we already prepare our ESG reports to be CSRD-compatible.

Reporting in a smaller company

So there is no need to panic. We all know that when someone says European Union, directive, legislation, everyone imagines a very complicated process. So how complicated is ESG really? There is no simple answer. We have said that large companies report within the established, most widely used standards – accounting-based IFRS, analytical TCFD and structured GRI. Reporting of this kind is of course very complex, and it suits multinational corporations.

They publish their ESG report either separately or as part of their annual report, combining financial and non-financial reporting in the way corporations are used to. They then present the combined report to their shareholders, boards and other bodies, so that these have a good overview of the company’s position and strategy and can make informed decisions about its future direction.

At EnviTrail we also often come across cases where the Czech subsidiary of a multinational corporation has to provide structured information to its parent company. And as is often the case in a corporate environment, the instructions are either very vague or so detailed that they are impossible to understand. That is where an expert who understands ESG comes in and, reading between the lines, translates the parent company’s requirements into clear terms.

They can also help with the reporting itself in a practical way. That is the corporate world, where ESG reporting is gradually settling in. What keeps surprising us, however, is the remarkably strong interest in ESG among small and medium-sized companies. It is interesting how many smaller companies consider ESG important. Perhaps that is because ESG really is a very natural management tool. Smaller companies do not need a complicated system; they do not mind whether you follow GRI, TCFD, IFRS, SDG, CDP or BSR.

With experienced guidance, they can identify and write up their ESG in one or two half-day workshops. In principle, ESG is very intuitive.

What an ESG report contains

So what does ESG look like in practice? It is a structured report in the categories E – environment, S – social and G – governance.

The simplest approach is to take a list of categories like a Chinese restaurant menu and choose which categories apply to my company and which do not. On this slide we can see, as a concrete example, the categories used by the American technology exchange NASDAQ. The NASDAQ methodology is very clear and simple and also suits small companies, but if you are looking for inspiration, there are plenty of similar guidance tables on the internet. So I choose from these or similar ESG categories.

If I am a small company, board diversity will probably not be relevant to me, simply because I have no board, but energy consumption will certainly concern me. Conversely, for a large property developer, for example, the climate investment category will be very important, whereas child and forced labour in Europe will – let us hope – not be relevant.

Company goals and priorities

Always remember that ESG is a tool for strategic decision-making and for marketing. The topics identified therefore need to be developed further, given target values or target states, and prioritised. The established way of setting priorities is to divide them into three levels – ‘very important’, ‘we would like to do’ and ‘nice to have’.

For example, for a particular company the ‘greenhouse gases’ category may turn into a commitment to reduce its carbon footprint by 30% by 2030, while employee diversity may lead to setting up a company nursery to support women returning from maternity leave.

Publishing ESG reporting on the company website, for instance, is now standard practice, and some methodologies even strictly require it. The ESG reports of large corporations can run to dozens of pages, but the ESG report of a smaller company, or the executive summary of a comprehensive ESG report, fits on five pages.

On the first page you introduce your company; on the second you briefly describe your ESG methodology and present the specific topics, much as in this table. Then you devote one page each to the environment, social matters and governance.

At the same time, ESG is not yet very common, so if you want to get ahead of your competitors, now is the ideal time to start.